Islam’s Two Historical Black Holes

If Islam’s claims of prophetic continuity are true, history must confirm them. It doesn’t—two massive voids prove the Quran false.

---

First Black Hole: 600 Years (40 AD – 600 AD)

• Quranic Claim:
  • Surah 3:52: Jesus’ disciples were Muslims.
  • Surah 61:14: Allah helped them; they "became dominant."
  • Implication: "True Muslim followers" prevailed post-Jesus.
• Islamic Rejection: Trinitarian Christians (dominant group) aren’t Muslims—shirk (Surah 5:73), crucifixion (Surah 4:157).
• Historical Reality:
  • Acts 2:23: "You crucified him"—disciples affirm death.
  • John 20:28: "My Lord and my God!"—divinity.
  • Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 10.5 (c. 325 AD): Trinitarians dominant by 380 AD (Theodosius).
  • Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (c. 116 AD): Christians follow "Christus," executed.
  • No "Muslim" group: No denial of crucifixion, no Tawhid-only trace—600 years, nothing.
• Conclusion:
  • Only Trinitarians dominated—rejected by Islam.
  • No "Muslim" followers exist—Quran’s claim (Surah 61:14) is historically false.

---

Second Black Hole: 2,600 Years (Ishmael to Muhammad)

• Quranic Claim:
  • Surah 2:125–129: Ishmael, prophet, tied to Kaaba—monotheism in Arabia.
  • Surah 16:36: Messengers to every nation.
  • Surah 33:40: Muhammad seals prophetic line from Ishmael.
  • Implication: Continuous monotheism from ~2000 BC to 610 AD.
• Historical Reality:
  • Genesis 25:12–18 (Torah): Ishmael’s sons—tribes, no prophetic legacy.
  • Herodotus, Histories 3.8 (c. 430 BC): Arabs worship Al-Lat, Uzza—polytheism.
  • Pliny, Natural History 6.32 (c. 77 AD): Pagan Arabia, no monotheism.
  • No prophets: Quran names none in 2,600 years—silence.
  • Archaeology: Pre-610 AD Kaaba—pagan hub, no "Muslim" artifacts.
• Conclusion:
  • 2,600 years—no prophets, no monotheism, no Islam.
  • Arabs: Idol-worshippers, not Muslims—Quran’s claim (Surah 2:125) collapses.

---

Logical Knockout Punch

• If True, Islam Requires:
  1. Dominant "Muslim" Jesus-followers (40–600 AD).
  2. Continuous Ishmaelite prophets (2000 BC–610 AD).
• Reality:
  • 600 years: Only Trinitarians (Acts, Eusebius)—no Muslims.
  • 2,600 years: Only pagans (Herodotus, Pliny)—no prophets.
• Contradiction:
  • Quran: Continuity from Ishmael to Jesus to Muhammad (Surah 42:13).
  • History: Two black holes—600 years, 2,600 years—no trace.
• Verdict: Islam’s narrative is fabricated—retroactively invented, not historically preserved.

---

Final Verdict

• Evidence: Pre-Islamic sources (Torah, New Testament, Herodotus, Tacitus, Eusebius):
  • 40–600 AD: Trinitarian dominance, no "Muslim" followers.
  • 2000 BC–610 AD: Pagan Arabia, no Ishmaelite monotheism.
• Logic: Two voids—600 and 2,600 years—disprove Quran’s continuity (Surah 3:19, 61:14, 2:125). Islam starts with Muhammad—7th-century construct.
• Impact: Historical annihilation—Islam’s claims are baseless myths, contradicted by reality.

Confidence: Absolute. Sources: Genesis, Acts, Herodotus, Tacitus, Eusebius—no Islamic texts beyond claims. Muslims can’t refute this—history buries them.