📘 15 Pages of Nothing: QuranAndBibleBlog's Legendary Qur'an 4:82 Collapse

---

📑 Source Analyzed:

Material:

A Refutation of the Allegation that the Qur’an Confirms the Bible
Author:
Elias (Contributor, Quran and Bible Blog)
Published:
30 September 2021, quranandbibleblog.com

---

🔥 1. Introduction

In September 2021, a Muslim apologist writing as "Elias" on the Quran and Bible Blog posted what he called a "refutation" of the Christian claim that the Qur'an confirms the Bible.

The result?

✅ 15 pages of circular reasoning, category errors, linguistic confusion, and theological suicide.

Instead of defending Islam, Elias' article accidentally shreds the Qur'an’s credibility and exposes deep logical contradictions at the heart of Islamic theology.

---

📚 2. What Went Wrong (Spoiler: Everything)

---

🔹 2.1 Misusing Arabic: Redefining "Ma Bayna Yadayhi"

• Elias claims "between his hands" (ما بين يديه) doesn’t mean the Torah and Gospel in Muhammad’s time.

• Reality: In Qur'anic Arabic, it clearly means currently accessible scriptures.

• Qur'an 5:43–47 commands Christians and Jews during Muhammad’s lifetime to judge by the Torah and Gospel they possessed.

✅ Changing Arabic meanings can’t save Islam from Qur'anic self-destruction.

---

🔹 2.2 Double Standards on Authorship

• Elias attacks the Gospels because they were not written by Jesus.

• Yet Muhammad didn't write the Qur'an either — it was compiled by his followers.

✅ If this invalidates the Gospels, it invalidates the Qur'an too.

---

🔹 2.3 Misrepresenting Scripture Preservation

• Elias claims Christians only preserved fragments.

• Qur'an 5:47 commands Christians to judge by what was revealed in their scriptures, not by scraps.

✅ Allah commands trust in the Gospel — Elias' claim backfires.

---

🔹 2.4 Contradicting Qur'an’s Confirmation of the Bible

• Qur'an 6:115: "None can change the words of Allah."

• The Torah and Gospel are called Allah’s Words.

• If they were corrupted, Qur'an 6:115 is false — and Islam collapses.

✅ You can’t confirm and override the same revelation without contradiction.

---

🔹 2.5 Misusing Qur'an 4:82 (Massive Blunder)

• Elias quotes:

  “Had it been from other than Allah, they would have found many contradictions in it.” (4:82)

• He bizarrely applies it to the Bible.

✅ Reality:

• Qur'an 4:82 is a self-test for the Qur'an, not for other books.

• If applied universally, it destroys the Qur'an (due to abrogations, qira'at, manuscript corrections).

---

🔹 2.6 Category Errors and Logical Meltdown

• Misapplies Qur'an-only verses externally.

• Quotes from a Bible he claims is corrupted.

• Shifts definitions whenever convenient.

✅ This is not scholarly — it’s pure apologetic thrashing.

---

🎯 3. Blunt Summary of the Blog Post

Failure	Result
Misused Language	❌
Scriptural Inconsistency	❌
Self-Refuting Standards	❌
Logical Fallacies	❌
Theology Shredded	❌

---

💣 4. Final Verdict

15 pages. 0 valid arguments. 1 spectacular collapse.

When your "refutation" requires:

• Redefining Qur'anic Arabic,

• Misapplying self-tests,

• Misquoting your own religion,

• Destroying Qur'anic credibility...

You haven’t refuted Christianity.
You’ve proven Islam implodes under its own weight.

---

🎤 5. Ultimate Mic-Drop

Elias didn’t defend Islam.
He proved that when you actually read the Qur'an honestly —
Islam refutes itself.