Wednesday, April 23, 2025

“If Allah Didn’t Make These Mistakes — Then Who Did?”

The Final Collapse of the Corruption Narrative in Islam


🧭 Introduction

After examining what the Qur’an actually says about the Torah, Injil, and Zabur, a devastating truth becomes impossible to ignore:

The Qur’an affirms the earlier scriptures — yet Islamic theology later accuses them of corruption.

This contradiction isn’t small. It isn’t academic. It isn’t a debate about interpretation.

It is fatal.

Because if the Qur’an affirms corrupted books, then it is not the word of an all-knowing God.
And if Allah didn’t make these mistakes… then someone else did.


📜 What the Qur’an Says

The Torah, Injil, and Zabur were given by Allah

  • Surah 3:3 — “He revealed the Torah and the Gospel.”

  • Surah 4:163 — “We gave David the Zabur.”

They were still in use and authoritative in Muhammad’s time

  • Surah 5:47 — “Let the People of the Gospel judge by what Allah has revealed therein.”

  • Surah 7:157 — “...whom they find written with them in the Torah and the Gospel.”

Allah’s word cannot be altered

  • Surah 6:115 — “None can alter the words of Allah.”

  • Surah 10:64 — “No change is there in the words of Allah.”


💣 The Contradiction

Islamic theology claims:

“The Bible was corrupted. The Gospels are not the real Injil. The Torah has been changed.”

But the Qur’an says:

“They still have it. It’s from Allah. Judge by it. No one can change it.”

So which is it?

  • If the Bible was corrupted, Allah endorsed a forgery — impossible.

  • If the Bible was not corrupted, then Islam has no need to exist — its foundational claim of correction collapses.

  • If Allah didn’t know it was corrupted, He’s not all-knowing.

  • If He knew and still said to follow it, then He deceives.

All options destroy Islamic theology.


⚖️ If Allah Didn't Make These Mistakes…

Then who did?

  • Who confused the Injil Jesus received with something else?

  • Who claimed Allah’s word can’t be changed — then claimed it was?

  • Who needed to invalidate previous scriptures to make Islam necessary?

The answer is clear:

❌ It wasn't a perfect God.
✅ It was men — trying to retroactively fix contradictions between the Qur’an and reality.

Men like:

  • Ibn Hazm (11th century), who first accused the Bible of textual corruption.

  • Ibn Taymiyyah, who expanded the attack.

  • Generations of scholars who rewrote theology to protect Islam from collapse.


🧠 The Law of Identity Strikes Again

Injil = The Gospel given to Jesus.
The Qur’an calls what Christians had in the 7th century the Injil.
❌ You cannot redefine a thing mid-sentence.
❌ You cannot call a forgery “the word of Allah.”

That’s not divine.
That’s desperate damage control.


🚨 Final Verdict

  • The Qur’an calls the Torah and Gospels divine, unaltered, and still in use.

  • Islamic theology contradicts this.

  • These contradictions are not small — they strike at the core of Islam’s claims.

And so, we ask again:

If Allah didn’t make these mistakes… who did?

📌 Not God.
📌 Not a prophet.
A man — trying to clean up a theological mess.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Did Isa of the Qur’an Really Exist as a Real Historical Person? A hard historical answer to a question that is too often blurred, softened,...