Apostasy in Islam
Freedom of Religion Ends Where Muhammad Begins
7 Part Series
Introduction
Part I: No Compulsion? The Qur’an’s Contradictions on Apostasy
Forget the pamphlet slogans. "No compulsion in religion" is not the end of the story—it's the start of a bait-and-switch. Islam invites belief with open arms, then locks the door behind you. Apostasy—leaving Islam—is not just frowned upon. It's criminal. It's deadly. It's divine treason.
Qur'an 4:89: "If they turn back [from Islam], seize them and kill them wherever you find them."
Sahih Bukhari 6922: "Whoever changes his religion, kill him."
From Muhammad himself to the classical jurists to modern Islamic governments, the message is clear: Islam isn't just a religion. It's a cartel—you can join freely, but try to leave and you’ll meet the theological equivalent of a hit squad.
Part II: The Prophet of Death Sentences — Muhammad on Apostasy
Muhammad wasn’t just a prophet—he was the precedent.
He ordered the killing of apostates personally:
Abdullah ibn Khatal: Executed while clinging to the Kaaba.
The Prophet’s orders were not for rebels—they were for believers turned doubters.
Hadith sources? Ironclad:
Sahih Muslim 1676: Three reasons for death: murder, adultery, and leaving Islam.
Sahih Bukhari 2854: Lists people executed for apostasy and mockery.
He didn’t debate them. He didn’t pray for them. He didn’t “let God judge their hearts.” He killed them.
This isn't fringe. This is foundational.
Part III: Shariah on Apostasy — Death, Beheading, No Regret Required
Every major Sunni school of jurisprudence (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, Hanbali) agrees:
Apostasy is punishable by death.
Women may get a grace period—but the end result is still execution.
Manual of Islamic Law, Reliance of the Traveller, o8.0–o8.5: Death for leaving Islam.
This is not “medieval misinterpretation.” It’s systemic doctrine, preserved for over 1,000 years.
And the so-called "tolerance" of the Ottomans or Andalusian Islam? Still killed apostates. Just sometimes more politely.
Part IV: Apostasy Laws Today — Islam Meets the Human Rights Guillotine
Fast forward to today:
Iran: Apostasy punishable by death.
Saudi Arabia: Leaving Islam = terrorism under anti-terror law.
Pakistan: Converts executed under blasphemy statutes.
Afghanistan (Taliban rule): Apostates hunted and executed.
According to Humanists International’s 2024 report:
12+ Islamic countries impose death or imprisonment for apostasy.
Even in the West, apostates suffer:
Families disown or abuse them.
Community leaders call for their execution.
Ex-Muslim groups require anonymity for safety.
Freedom of religion? Only on the entry side.
Part V: The Illusion of Reform — Apologetics, Gaslighting, and Theological Gymnastics
When confronted, modern apologists twist themselves into theological yoga:
"It was about treason!" — But hadith say nothing about war.
"The hadith is weak!" — But it’s in Bukhari. You trust it for everything else.
"No compulsion in religion!" — That verse (Q2:256) was abrogated.
"Jesus also taught harsh things!" — But Christianity isn’t legally executing apostates in 2025.
Let’s not sugarcoat it: Islam has never renounced apostasy laws. It has merely rebranded them.
If your faith needs a PR team, it’s not faith—it’s marketing.
Part VI: Ex-Muslims Speak — Stories of Courage, Torture, and Escape
Real people. Real persecution.
Rana Ahmad (Saudi Arabia): Fled on foot after her family threatened to kill her.
Mohammed Hegazy (Egypt): Tried to change his religion legally. Arrested, tortured.
Avijit Roy (Bangladesh): Murdered with machetes for writing critically about Islam.
These are not isolated cases. Apostates face:
Social death
Physical abuse
State-sanctioned violence
Eternal hellfire threats
Western governments? Too scared to speak. Muslim communities? Too complicit to act. Liberals? Too busy calling apostates "Islamophobic" to care.
Part VII: The Core Contradiction — “Religion of Peace” Meets the Apostate’s Grave
Islam claims to be peaceful.
Islam kills people for leaving.
Those statements cannot coexist.
Sahih Bukhari 6922: “Whoever changes his religion, kill him.” Qur’an 4:89: “If they turn back, seize and kill them wherever you find them.”
This isn’t the edge of Islam. This is the center.
“You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave.”
— Hotel California, The Eagles
That’s Islam’s theology of apostasy: A hotel you enter by invitation and leave in a body bag.
And until the Qur’an is rewritten, the Hadith annulled, and Muhammad's example disavowed, this system cannot coexist with freedom, conscience, or basic morality.
Final Verdict: Faith Backed by Fear Isn’t Faith — It’s Fascism
Islam didn’t tolerate apostasy. It declared war on it.
Muhammad didn’t forgive apostates. He executed them.
Sharia didn’t evolve past it. It doubled down.
And to this day, Muslims who dare to leave often pay in blood.
If a religion cannot be left without threat of violence, then what it needs is not protection.
What it needs is exposure.
⚠️ Disclaimer
This post critiques Islam as an ideology, doctrine, and historical system—not Muslims as individuals. Every human deserves dignity. Beliefs do not. Truth-telling is not hate. Silence is.
📚 Bibliography & Sources
Sahih Bukhari 6922, 2854, 3017
Sahih Muslim 1676
Qur’an 2:256, 4:89, 9:5
Reliance of the Traveller (Umdat al-Salik) o8.0–o8.5
Ibn Kathir, Tafsir on 2:256, 4:89
Sadakat Kadri, Heaven on Earth: A Journey Through Shari'a Law
Jonathan A.C. Brown, Misquoting Muhammad
Kecia Ali, The Lives of Muhammad
Faith to Faithless, Ex-Muslim support org
Maryam Namazie, Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain
Humanists International, Freedom of Thought Report (2024)
Human Rights Watch, Apostasy and Blasphemy Reports (2022–2024)
Open Doors, World Watch List: Apostasy Cases
Eagles, Hotel California (lyrics)
No comments:
Post a Comment